Fans of NCIS have been eagerly awaiting news of what’s next for the franchise, and the latest spinoff may be delivering something truly special—a long-awaited return of a character who hasn’t been seen in nearly 19 years. With NCIS: Origins set to explore the early days of Gibbs’ career, rumors are swirling that a young version of Special Agent Caitlin Todd could make a surprise appearance, reigniting emotional connections to one of the show’s most tragic losses.

Caitlin Todd, played by Sasha Alexander, was a core member of the original team before her shocking and emotional death in season two. Her sudden departure left a lasting impact on the series and its characters, especially Gibbs and DiNozzo. Now, with Origins diving into the early dynamics of Gibbs’ rise through NCIS, the stage is set to revisit Todd in a new light—possibly through flashbacks, archival material, or a reimagined introduction.

This possibility has left longtime fans buzzing with excitement and nostalgia. Bringing back Todd—even in a younger version—could deepen the show’s emotional roots and offer new insight into Gibbs’ early influences. It would also honor her legacy in a meaningful way, acknowledging the role she played in shaping the heart of the team.

While nothing is officially confirmed, the buzz surrounding this beloved character’s potential return continues to grow. If NCIS: Origins follows through, it could become one of the most talked-about moments in the franchise’s history, giving fans a powerful reunion they never expected to see.